National Banks Are Turning Green … With Worry

Central banks stepped into the breach to stabilize banks and restore growth after the global financial crisis — now, green campaigners would like them to take on the yet bigger challenge of making sure the financial system penalizes carbon-intensive assets and funds the transition to clean energy.

» Top New Products

Hardcore Fighting Secrets

Shows  You  Actual  COMBAT  REALITY  and  How  to  Stop  HARDCORE  VIOLENT  ATTACKS                                                       

Vehicle History Reports

If  you  want  to  save  on  Carfax  Vehicle  History  Reports,  you  are  in  the  right  place  to  get  started       

Improve Your PCs Performance

Learn  The  Safest  And  Easiest  Way  To  Improve  Your  PC  Performance  Is  Just  A  Mouse  Click  Away                   

Make a 1920's Dress

How  to  make  a  1920s  flapper  style  dress  in  only  one  hour.                                                                                     

Production Scheduling Excel

Scheduler123  :  Excel-based  Finite  Production  Scheduling  Software.                                                                     

The Benefits of Manuka Honey

Learn  the  Top  10  Benefits  and  Uses  of  Manuka  Honey  and  how  it  can  change  your  life  today.                     

Beekeeping Made Easy

Learn  to  produce  your  own  Honey  Become  a  beekeeper  today,  only  $24                                                                   

Wordpress Security Guide

Ultimate  WordPress  Security  Manual.  Reveals  How  To  Defend  Wp  Site  Against  Hackers.                                   

The Travel Hacker's Toolkit

Here's  How  To  Guarantee  You  Get  The  Cheapest  Flight  Available,  EVERY  Time...                                               

Assemble Crafts at Home

Work  at  home  assemble    and    crafts  jobs    and    get  payed  for  it  jobs  offered  by  companies.                     

Play chess on the web for free

Stan's  NetChess  -  Your  Address  for  Correspondence  Chess  in  the  Internet  Age                                                 

Find Your Dream Tattoo Now

View  Our  Collection  Of  Over  7,500  Unique  Tattoo  Designs                                                                                         


Only recently have central banks seen any role in managing the systemic risks of climate change — the effects of which will largely be felt well beyond the horizon of regulators and rate-setters. In 2015, Mark Carney, Bank of England governor, was widely accused of overstepping his remit when he urged action on what he called a “tragedy of the horizon,” arguing that “once climate change becomes a clear and present danger to financial stability, it may already be too late.”

to curb emissions and speed the adoption of green technology have the potential to trigger sharp falls in asset prices. These risks once seemed too distant for most financial institutions — insurers apart — to worry about, but many of them are now starting to materialize.

London could flood in any one year.

Paul Fisher, former Bank of England policymaker

Now, most accept in principle that climate change threatens financial stability. More frequent extremes of weather will damage property and disrupt trade, while policies

“London could flood in any one year. It’s a long-term risk, it goes up over time, but it could happen anytime,” says Paul Fisher, a former Bank of England policymaker who is a fellow at Cambridge University’s Institute for Sustainability Leadership.

For financial institutions, the “transition risks” of policy changes are both more immediate and more serious. Mortgage lenders’ loan books will look more risky and so require more capital held against them if governments decide it is uneconomic to protect certain areas from flooding — now a realistic threat to property prices along swaths of the U.K. coastline.

Frank Elderson, a member of the Netherlands central bank’s governing board, points to proposals for new standards on energy efficiency as another example: These could strand real estate assets and potentially affect any bank that has loaned to companies using their office buildings as collateral.

So far, prudential regulators at the Bank of England and Dutch central bank have done the most to make banks, as well as insurers, take these risks seriously. Last month, the BoE told institutions they would need to establish board-level engagement and responsibility for managing climate change risks — a step that means senior executives will be held personally accountable. Others are inclined to follow suit. In October, 18 central banks and supervisors, members of a new Network for Greening the Financial System (NGFS), signed a declaration stating that climate-related risks fell squarely within their mandate. The U.S. Federal Reserve and Bank of Japan, operating in a different political climate, are notable exceptions. But the European Central Bank — although hypersensitive to anything that could be construed as stretching its remit — recently told banks that it counted climate risks among the key threats to the euro area banking system.

However, most central banks oppose calls for them to support sustainable finance by lowering capital requirements for green lending and penalizing “brown” assets. Without clear evidence that green finance carried lower risks, such a policy “could compromise the key objective of maintaining capital buffers, which is to safeguard the system of sound and solvent banks,” the Dutch central bank said last month.

Instead, their focus is on better disclosure of risks.

In theory, this is not a change in supervisors’ powers or remit — institutions should already be flagging up any risks material to their business and holding capital against them. But it requires a big cultural shift because risk managers usually make their judgments by crunching historical data. Most climate risks lie in the future.

A task force of the international Financial Stability Board — chaired by Carney — has set out recommendations designed to help firms measure risk. In particular, it encourages them to use scenario analysis — for example, modeling how their business would need to change if governments took the actions required to limit the global rise in average temperature to 2C above pre-industrial levels.

At the moment, central banks’ focus — including through the NGFS — is on developing the tools risk managers will need. Green campaigners believe they should be doing a lot more, not only to police the climate-related risks to financial stability but also to catalyze green investment and to lead by example, in particular when they enter the markets to implement monetary policy.

This is far more controversial.

The ECB already applies ethical criteria to the asset portfolios underpinning staff pensions. It is exploring a similar approach for the investment of its paid-up capital and general reserves. Even here, there is an argument that targeting green assets could be counterproductive. “We are short of green assets, not of money to invest in them — if central banks go in, they could undercut the market,” says Fisher.

A group of economists writing in the FT, however, argue that central banks should also follow their own strictures on pricing climate-related risks when they lend money to banks against collateral. Otherwise — since assets accepted by a central bank enjoy lower yields — they are creating an “implicit subsidy” for fossil fuels.

In October, 18 central banks and supervisors declared that climate-related risks fell within their mandate.

Some central bankers counter that if disclosure is done correctly, capital will automatically flow toward more sustainable businesses.

“Once markets and credit risk agencies price climate risks properly, the amount of collateralized borrowing counterparties can obtain from the ECB will be adjusted accordingly,” Benoit Coeuré, an ECB governing board member, said last month.

The biggest question is whether climate risks should have any bearing on central banks’ conduct of monetary policy. It is much harder to justify skewing the vast asset purchases made under quantitative easing programs to the pursuit of green objectives — or anything other than the primary objective of ensuring macroeconomic stability.

“You have to think very carefully about the motives for central bank intervention,” Fisher says. Governments could add climate goals to central banks’ remits as a secondary objective, or clarify what is meant by sustainable growth so that policymakers feel able to do more when it does not interfere with their core mission. However, Fisher warns: “They have no power to do anything about climate change. … If you don’t keep control of inflation and macroeconomic stability, you lose any long-term agenda.”


By Delphine Strauss

OZY partners with the U.K.’s Financial Times to bring you premium analysis and features. © The Financial Times Limited 2018.

Let’s block ads! (Why?)

Post Author: martin

Martin is an enthusiastic programmer, a webdeveloper and a young entrepreneur. He is intereted into computers for a long time. In the age of 10 he has programmed his first website and since then he has been working on web technologies until now. He is the Founder and Editor-in-Chief of and Online Magazines. His colleagues appreciate him as a passionate workhorse, a fan of new technologies, an eternal optimist and a dreamer, but especially the soul of the team for whom he can do anything in the world.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.