As the Timeless series finale neared its end and the Time Team scored its biggest win yet, captured nemesis Emma dangled one last tease before Lucy: the prospect of getting back the sister who vanished from the timeline at the close of the Season 1 premiere.
“Wait — I can bring Amy back.”
“She’s lying,” Lucy (played by Abigail Spencer) scoffed.
“Try me,” Emma (Annie Wersching) countered. “I only [removed Amy from existence] because your mother ordered me to. But I can undo it. It means nothing to me and everything to you….”
“I want all of this to be over.”
“And you want your sister back. I can make that happen. You just have to trust me.”
After due consideration, Lucy responded, “I don’t” — and in doing so, she passed up any chance to have her sister back in her life.