DWTS Still Has a Popularity Problem (and the Judges’ Save Didn’t Fix It)

Before Dancing With the Stars kicked off its 28th season, ABC had hinted that some “format tweaks” were coming down the pike — and many a viewer breathed a sigh of relief.

» Top New Products

Stock Market Alerts

Stock  alerts  are  sent  daily  and  on  weekends  with  an  explanation  of  analysis                                                 

Massthetic Muscle

he  Complete  Guide  to  the  Art  of  Sculpting  Lean  Muscle  Mass  that  is  Aesthetically  Pleasing                     

Anti aging shortcuts

The  simple  and  scientifically  proven  way  to  looking  years  younger.                                                                   

Start Amazon FBA Business Today

Learn  How  To  Use  Amazon  Like  A  Professional,  And  Get  Live  Support  24  Hours  Everyday.                               

Adver Blast Unlimited Traffic

A  New  Type  Of  Exit  Exchange,  Have  Your  Ad  Rotated  For  Life  On  Tens  Of  Thousands  Of  Websites                 

Master Cleanse Secrets

10  Days  On  The  Master  Cleanse  Can  Turn  Your  Life  and  Health  Arround                                                                 

Human Anatomy Course

3000+  Pages  With  Detailed  Diagrams  Learn  Anatomy  Easily    and    Quickly                                                             

Find Car Auctions Now

Huge  Savings  on  Repos  and  Seized  Cars  from  the  Government  Surplus                                                                     

Feel Emotional Freedom

Discover  Emotional  Freedom  Techniques  Which  Releases  Stress,  Heal  Your  Heart    and    Master  Your  Mind.

Beekeeping Made Easy

Learn  to  produce  your  own  Honey  Become  a  beekeeper  today,  only  $24                                                                   

Teach Yourself Reiki Today

Attune  Yourself  to  Reiki,  Right  Now  Powerful  New  System  Shows  You  How                                                             

Secret To Manifest Anything You Want

Instantly  Manifest  Wealth,  Abundance  Or  Anything  You  Want  Under  Sky  In  6  Hours                                           


The tweaks would have been a welcome addition to any cycle, really: After 14 years on the air, DWTS needed a little tune-up, controversy notwithstanding. But the changes seemed especially necessary in the wake of Bobby Bones’ Season 27 victory, which left a large swath of the show’s fans annoyed that a weak dancer had won the Mirrorball trophy, while some frontrunners didn’t even reach the finale.

And yet, now that we’ve bid adieu to Season 28 — perhaps an even more polarizing cycle than the one that preceded it — it’s time to call a spade a spade: Dancing’s new format failed to fix the show’s problems.

I’m specifically referencing the new judges’ save, which allowed Len Goodman, Carrie Ann Inaba and Bruno Tonioli to choose which of the bottom two couples would go home each week. Shocking eliminations have happened on DWTS for years, but the judges’ save seemed designed to prevent that, allowing them to protect a strong duo that would otherwise go home prematurely.

But when the show introduced this twist, it was assuming that the weakest dancers would also get the least votes from America, paving the way for piece-of-cake decisions from the judges. And that didn’t happen. Instead, we got the baffling success of ex-White House press secretary Sean Spicer, who got enough votes to snag sixth place (!) despite no visible improvement week over week.

DWTS Season 28It’s no secret that DWTS is often a popularity contest, rewarding well-liked contestants (or contestants who are giving it the ol’ college try) over those who dance well. But I’m still of the opinion that it shouldn’t be — and I’m not alone in that. In a recent TVLine poll, 44 percent of readers said they typically vote for the best and/or highest-scored dancers, while 22 percent typically show support for those who are improving each week. Only 11 percent said they vote for the most likable contestants, regardless of their skill, while 16 percent tend to rally behind the celebrity they already recognized.

Plus, the show also seems to want the strongest dancers to win. Anytime a frontrunner goes home too soon — like Season 28 hopefuls Sailor Brinkley-Cook or Kate Flannery — the judges find it “frustrating.” Hosts Tom Bergeron and Erin Andrews are stunned. The studio audience boos! And if the show didn’t value talent over popularity, why introduce the judges’ save at all? Why not just let the home audience call the shots?

But if the show really wants to keep the best dancers, the judges’ save isn’t enough — not when a weak contestant like Spicer can still get by on America’s votes, though he’s hardly the only amateur to survive on fan support alone. If the show is renewed for Season 29, perhaps the judges’ scores need to make up a bigger fraction of the final results. Or, at the risk of getting lambasted by the studio audience, the judges may simply need to score dancers more harshly if they’re not improving. (After all, there’s no world in which Spicer ever deserved sevens, is there?)

DWTS certainly gets kudos for trying something new; the judges’ save was an exciting addition to Season 28, even when it didn’t have the desired effect. But if the show truly wants to reward the best of the best (and it seems to want that!), a bigger and bolder change needs to step into the spotlight.

Let’s block ads! (Why?)


Post Author: martin

Martin is an enthusiastic programmer, a webdeveloper and a young entrepreneur. He is intereted into computers for a long time. In the age of 10 he has programmed his first website and since then he has been working on web technologies until now. He is the Founder and Editor-in-Chief of BriefNews.eu and PCHealthBoost.info Online Magazines. His colleagues appreciate him as a passionate workhorse, a fan of new technologies, an eternal optimist and a dreamer, but especially the soul of the team for whom he can do anything in the world.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.