Critics say Facebook’s ‘disputed’ news tag doesn’t go far enough

Mark ZuckerbergMariana Bazo/Reuters

» Top New Products

Search addresses
cs_image_0

Find  out  who  owns  that  email  address.  Worldwide  Coverage  Instant  Access.                                                       

$19.95
ULTIMATE INTIMACY BOOST
cs_image_1

Reignite  The  Spark  and  Experience  More  Passion,romance  and  an  intimate  bond  In  Your  Relationship       

$9.95
The Art Of Covert Hypnosis
cs_image_2

Learn  The  Easy-To-Master  SecretsTo  Hypnotizing  Anyone,  Anywhere                                                                         

$176.00
Add 60 Yards Of Straight As An Arrow
cs_image_3

Master  The  Kinetic  Chain    and    Add  20,  40,  Or  Even  60  Yards  Of  Distance  To  Every  Drive                           

$39.00
Learn How To Sing
cs_image_4

Sing  like  a  professional  starting  today                                                                                                                         

$49.95
Produce Management Accounts
cs_image_5

Increase  Your  Understanding  Of  The  Practical  World  And  Boost  Your  Confidence.                                             

$20.23
Weekly Updated PLR Membership
cs_image_6

The  Internet's  largest  and  most  reputable  PLR  membership  site.                                                                           

$19.00
Curiouser and curiouser
cs_image_7

101  Famous  Quotes  from  Alice  in  Wonderland.  New  illustrations.                                                                           

$19.50
Web graphics package
cs_image_8

This  book  contains  thousands  of  professional  web  graphics  at  your  fingertips.                                             

$27.00
Car leasing kit and guide
cs_image_9

For  smart  automotive  consumers.  Learn  how  to  lease  your  car  and  save                                                               

$19.95
The Lost Book Of Remedies
cs_image_10

Helping  Americans  achieve  curative  self-sufficiency  even  in  the  darkest  times.                                           

$37.00
The Blue Sky Guide To Linkedin
cs_image_11

LinkedIn  can  help  you  build  the  career  you've  always  hoped  for,  with  minimal  effort.                               

$29.00

MARCH 6, 2017 —Facebook released a new system to fight the spread of fake news on Friday amid ongoing pressure from groups calling for more accurate information from the site many rely on as a significant news source.

While the review of news articles by independent fact-checkers could have a positive effect, some critics say the new feature does not go far enough to stop the proliferation of false or misleading information.

The new feature allows some users to tag news as fake, and flags certain articles with untrue or misleading information based on the diagnosis of fact-checking sites like Snopes or Politifact.

Stories with dubious facts will be marked by Facebook as “disputed,” and will be accompanied with a link to an article explaining why, though users will still be allowed to share the stories if they wish.

“This is a good first step, but I don’t necessarily think that we’re going to see a dramatic decrease in fake news any time soon,” says Elizabeth Cohen, a professor of communication studies at West Virginia University in Morgantown, W.Va.

Dr. Cohen, who specializes in the psychology of social media, tells The Christian Science Monitor in an email that there is a lot of gray area in fake news that makes it difficult to deal with, especially online. 

“The lines between editorial content, bias, half-truths, and blatant lies can be so blurred, I’m not sure that stopping the proliferation of fake news should even be the aim,” she writes. “The best-case scenario is that a system like this will raise people’s level of awareness about the presence of misinformation in their news diet.”

According to the Pew Research Center, 62 percent of US adults got news from social media last year, and 18 percent reported turning to social media often for their news. That’s a majority of adults who could potentially be susceptible to the distorted reports or outright hoaxes that often run rampant on social media.

And that puts companies like Facebook in a tough position. 

Unlike traditional news media outlets, committed to informing their readers and viewers with accuracy and integrity, social media platforms were designed for entertainment. But with so many people turning to them as a convenient way to learn about current events, sites such as Facebook and others like it have found themselves forced to take a political and social stand that, as businesses, they never wanted to make.

“I do think Facebook is taking a risk by becoming an actor in a very political situation,” says Cohen. “By attempting to police fake news, the company could be perceived as partisan and it could lose user trust.” 

presidential election debate trump clintonPatrick Semansky/AP

Fake news began to make real headlines leading up to the November election, when the internet was inundated with sensational, attention-grabbing, and untrue headlines meant to appeal especially to potential Trump voters. Notable examples included the assertion that Pope Francis had endorsed then-candidate Donald Trump for president, and that Hillary Clinton was linked to a child sex ring operating out of a pizza parlor.

The latter case nearly ended tragically when an armed man went to investigate the parlor in question. Fortunately, no one was injured.

These sensational headlines, and others like them, spread like wildfire, in part because of their very implausibility, making Facebook a great deal of ad revenue in the process. The articles’ popularity, in turn, caused many people to doubt legitimate news organizations who seemed to be refusing to cover the “real” events described in such articles, even after many were debunked. 

“The problem is that we are too credulous of news that reinforces our predispositions and too critical of sites that contradict them,” Brendan Nyhan, a political scientist at Dartmouth College in Hanover, N.H., told the Monitor in December.

These “echo chambers” of opinion and confirmation bias are nothing new, but the increasing politicization of fake news has only made the problem worse. Before the election, most fake news was aimed toward conservative readers, but since then, there has been a spike in fake news for liberals as well. This proliferation can make it harder for many people to differentiate what information is true, even after being presented with the facts.

“There’s a psychological phenomenon called the ‘backfire effect’ in which people tend to hold on to incorrect beliefs more strongly after being presented with factual information that contradicts those beliefs,” says Cohen. “In other words, sometimes when you give people facts to refute misperceptions, it actually makes them more resistant to the truth.”

She adds that the “backfire effect” is not a new issue, and that there is no reason to believe it would be substantially exacerbated by the new Facebook system.
Mark ZuckerbergAssociated Press

But potential backfiring isn’t the only problem with the new “disputed” flags. Getting a fake news article fact-checked takes time, during which the article can be shared thousands of times. And users will still be able to share the flagged articles, with the only obstacle being a quick pop-up warning alerting the user as to the dubious nature of the link they are about to share.

“It’s a huge mistake to expect this system to help change people’s beliefs. If you’re expecting that, you’re going to be disappointed,” says Cohen. “Many will continue to reject the truth no matter how many times it’s fact-checked.”

But for people who still haven’t made up their minds, she says, this new system could be an important step in the right direction.

“Just about everyone has trouble navigating all of the news out there today,” Cohen adds. “This has the potential to help people make decisions.”  

NOW WATCH: Animated map shows the best and worst states to raise your family


Feedburner

Post Author: martin

Avatar
Martin is an enthusiastic programmer, a webdeveloper and a young entrepreneur. He is intereted into computers for a long time. In the age of 10 he has programmed his first website and since then he has been working on web technologies until now. He is the Founder and Editor-in-Chief of BriefNews.eu and PCHealthBoost.info Online Magazines. His colleagues appreciate him as a passionate workhorse, a fan of new technologies, an eternal optimist and a dreamer, but especially the soul of the team for whom he can do anything in the world.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.