The 71-year-old won over the hearts of the nation with her moves to All About That Bass and stunning Watermelon fruit cake, but alas, Paul Hollywood and Prue Leith felt otherwise.
Viewers were devastated by the result and flocked to Twitter to unite in their despair.
“The best moment for me has to be when Paul [Hollywood] cut into my watermelon cake,” she enthused. “I wanted to see inside it as much as the judges did, to see if it had baked through properly, and thank goodness it had.
“I did practice it twice at home so I must admit I wasn’t fazed by making it in the tent.
“I am comfortable making cakes and gateaux I could make them all day long, but throw me a challenge of a biscuit and a bread sculpture and I start going to pieces.”
Contestant Steven Carter-Bailey has already emerged as firm favourite to be crowned Channel 4’s first Bake Off champion, with bookmakers awarding the 34-year-old odds of 2/1.
Betway’s Alan Alger, said: “It’s no surprise Steven is the early favourite at 2/1 to be crowned winner of this series of Great British Bake Off.
“Steven has wowed the show’s judges in the first two weeks, and with two Baker of the Week accolades already to his name, we make him 5/2 to complete the hat-trick in tonight’s show.”
Great British Bake Off continues next Tuesday at 8pm on Channel 4.