Exploring the Impossibility of Full Decentralization

This article is originally published in Albaron Ventures.

» Top New Products

8 Days to End Procrastination
cs_image_0

End  Procrastination  Program  By  Dr.  Steve  G  Jones.  To  beat  procrastination  once  and  for  all                   

$19.95
Organic Health Protocol
cs_image_1

Live  a  healthier,  more  active  life    with  a  simple  but  revolutionary  7-day  program                                     

$9.00
Keyword Researcher - SEO Software
cs_image_2

The  coolest  SEO  tool  ever  made  in  the  history  of  man  on  this  planet.                                                               

$47.00
Comedy clinic
cs_image_3

The  Comedy  Writing  System  E-Book  is  HereNeed  a  system  for  writing  jokes?                                                       

$67.00
Quality at-bats academy
cs_image_4

Become  a  smarter    and    more  confident  ballplayer  with  the  quality  at-bats  mental  training.                   

$1.00
Learn how to freestyle rap here
cs_image_5

Learn  how  to  flow  your  own  songs  with  freestyle  rapping  here.                                                                             

$97.00
Qigong for happiness
cs_image_6

Now  you  can  learn  chinas  1500  year  old  stay  young,  health  and  energy  secret.                                               

$4.95
Domain graduate ebook
cs_image_7

Learn  the  correct  way  to  become  a  domainer  instead  of  figuring  it  out                                                             

$19.99
Freight broker bootcamp
cs_image_8

Learn  how  to  become  a  freight  broker  or  freight  agent  in  less  than  30  days                                                   

$98.00
Penis Enlargement Remedy
cs_image_9

5  Steps  To  Growing  Your  Penis  By  2-4  Inches                                                                                                                 

$47.00
16,000 Woodworking Plans
cs_image_10

Instant  Access  To  Over  16,000  Woodworking  Plans  Plus  Step-By-Step  Videos                                                       

$67.00
Real Beauty Breakthrough
cs_image_11

A  natural  and  easy  way  that  may  help  towards  you  enjoying  firmer,  smoother,  younger-looking  skin       

$47.00

In our quest to escape from existing corrupt centralized systems, we may believe that it’s possible to achieve complete decentralization. However, recent academic research shows that this is unfeasible — at least sustainably.

For example, Bitcoin’s Proof-of-Work (PoW) mechanism relies on many different nodes to “mine,” or verify and facilitate transactions. These miners are rewarded a portion of transaction fees and a shot at winning the Bitcoin block reward, which is currently 12.5 bitcoins or about $115,000– a not insignificant prize dished out about 144 times per day.

This has incentivized the creation of “mining pools,” or a collection of nodes that work together and divide the prize among the operators. Mining pools have taken what would otherwise be a decentralized utopia and coalesced a degree of centralization. The current state of Bitcoin mining is far from a single entity controlling the network with a  51% lion’s share, but it still highlights the downfalls of decentralization.

Image via blockchain.com

There are cryptocurrencies that utilize different consensus mechanisms such as Proof-of-Stake and Delegated-Proof-of-Stake, and they manage to address some of Bitcoin’s drawbacks (such as high energy costs to mine), but they still leave the glaring decentralization issue.

A particularly noteworthy concept is that Bitcoin, a network with no single individual party dictating its future, has gravitated towards centralization on its own. Centralized entities may receive some flak in the cryptocurrency and blockchain community, but they are at least able to enforce and control certain elements, a task nearly impossible for a theoretical, fully decentralized entity.

Do we really need full decentralization?

The core tenet of decentralization, at least among the common blockchain ethos, is that decentralization insulates the network from tyranny and corruption, a duo that has plagued human governance and economics since the dawn of organized civilization.

The same concepts that power Adam Smith’s “free market” philosophy that underpins modern economics encourage decentralization as long as every party is properly incentivized (mining rewards) and has access to somewhat similar resources (electricity, reasonable utility costs, etc) as the next.

The glory of today’s blockchains isn’t so much derived from the idea of a utopian decentralization, but more so as a rebellion against the status quo of centralized banks dictating the economy, individuals being tethered to the success of their government, and the ability for large tech corporations and banks to shut down financial accounts at will.

There are several degrees of “decentralization”, and even though not “perfect,” even smaller decentralization improvements can be disruptive to the existing “centralized” status quo. 

The goal is to figure out which areas will be impacted first; and which are the top use cases given the infrastructure’s properties (security, decentralization, scalability).

For example, think of the idea of a decentralized “Uber,” a popular thought experiment in the blockchain entrepreneurial community. When someone needs a car to pick them up, what would they prefer: a nearly immediate connection to a driver courtesy of an efficient centralized server, or waiting for minutes and potentially hours for the transaction to be verified and processed?

Final Thoughts

Although the push towards absolute decentralization is unfeasible, and in reality, decentralization benefits vary across use cases. Simply put, we don’t need decentralization for everything– centralization tends to work just fine for most things, and it shouldn’t be viewed as an enemy of what the blockchain movement seeks to accomplish.

Ultimately, blockchain is simply just another technology to be leveraged to solve certain problems.

Once upon a time, centralization was the solution to the disorganized chaos of the unpredictable. Our ancestors who lived in groups tended to live longer and better lives than individuals not in groups.

These groups evolved into tribes that utilizes some form of centralization (leadership, hierarchy, enforced order) that protected its members and utilized resources more efficiently. Eventually, tribes expanded and, however indirectly, ended up becoming countries that function using the same centralized mechanics.

Decentralization uses the evolution of the Internet and technological infrastructure to create systems that don’t require a centralized entity’s direct oversight. However, decentralized entities can only function within the scope of a centralized society.

Today’s projects are able to enjoy both the benefits of existing within the confines of a centralized society and the possibilities enabled by blockchain and the Internet. While full decentralization might be impossible, there’s no reason to fuss.

Post Author: martin

Avatar
Martin is an enthusiastic programmer, a webdeveloper and a young entrepreneur. He is intereted into computers for a long time. In the age of 10 he has programmed his first website and since then he has been working on web technologies until now. He is the Founder and Editor-in-Chief of BriefNews.eu and PCHealthBoost.info Online Magazines. His colleagues appreciate him as a passionate workhorse, a fan of new technologies, an eternal optimist and a dreamer, but especially the soul of the team for whom he can do anything in the world.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.